The Speculative Attack on Fiat Currency

In 2014, Pierre Rochard authored a paper titled "Speculative Attack," published by the Nakamoto Institute, which provided a thought-provoking analysis on the dynamics of currency markets and the potential for Bitcoin to challenge fiat currencies through speculative attacks. The paper outlines the mechanics of a speculative attack, its potential impact on fiat currencies, and why Bitcoin, with its unique properties, could become a central player in such financial scenarios.

Key Points from the Paper

1. Mechanics of a Speculative Attack:

   • A speculative attack occurs when investors, anticipating a devaluation of a fiat currency, borrow in that currency to purchase a more stable asset, typically gold or foreign currency. This borrowing leads to a surge in demand for the alternative asset, while the fiat currency is sold off, accelerating its depreciation.

   • The paper posits that Bitcoin, with its finite supply and decentralized nature, is an ideal candidate for being the asset of choice during such an attack.

2. Bitcoin’s Unique Attributes:

   • Fixed Supply: Bitcoin's capped supply at 21 million coins stands in stark contrast to fiat currencies, which can be printed in unlimited quantities by central banks. This fixed supply is likened to gold but with added benefits.

   • Decentralization: Unlike gold, which is susceptible to government confiscation or manipulation, Bitcoin operates on a decentralized network, making it more resilient to state interference.

   • Ease of Transfer: Bitcoin's digital nature allows for easy and rapid transfer across borders, making it an efficient tool for moving wealth during times of economic instability.

3. The Process of Attack Using Bitcoin:

   • Investors could leverage their holdings in fiat currency to buy Bitcoin, anticipating that as the fiat currency devalues, Bitcoin’s value in terms of that currency would rise.

   • This shift would create a self-fulfilling prophecy where the declining value of fiat currency drives more people to buy Bitcoin, further accelerating the fiat's depreciation.

4. Historical Context and Implications:

   • Rochard draws parallels with historical speculative attacks, such as those on the British pound in 1992 and the Thai baht in 1997, to illustrate how Bitcoin could trigger similar scenarios on a global scale.

   • He argues that central banks’ interventions, such as raising interest rates or selling reserves, may not be effective against a decentralized asset like Bitcoin.

Salient Quotes

1. “As Bitcoin's liquidity increases, the potential for its use in speculative attacks against fiat currencies grows.”

2. “Bitcoin’s fixed supply is a stark contrast to the unlimited supply of fiat currencies, making it an attractive store of value.”

3. “A successful speculative attack on a fiat currency would be a major step towards Bitcoin becoming a global reserve currency.”

Changes Over the Last Decade

Since 2014, several key developments have influenced the potential for Bitcoin to participate in speculative attacks on fiat currencies:

1. Increased Adoption and Liquidity:

   • Bitcoin’s market capitalization has grown exponentially, enhancing its liquidity and making it a more viable candidate for large-scale speculative activities.

   • Institutional adoption has surged, with major companies and financial institutions incorporating Bitcoin into their portfolios, further stabilizing its market presence.

2. Regulatory Landscape:

   • Governments worldwide have increased their scrutiny and regulation of cryptocurrencies, aiming to mitigate risks associated with speculative attacks and financial instability.

   • Despite these regulations, Bitcoin's decentralized nature has continued to pose challenges to complete regulatory control.

3. Economic Instability and Inflation:

   • Over the past decade, economic instability and rising inflation in various countries have highlighted the vulnerabilities of fiat currencies, often leading to increased interest in Bitcoin as a hedge.

   • Events like hyperinflation in Venezuela and economic crises in Turkey have demonstrated real-world scenarios where Bitcoin has been used as an alternative store of value.

---

MicroStrategy and the Modern Speculative Attack: A Case Study

Since its adoption of a Bitcoin Treasury policy in 2020, MicroStrategy has become a prominent example of a modern speculative attack on fiat currency. Led by CEO Michael Saylor, the business intelligence firm has converted significant portions of its cash reserves into Bitcoin, a move that has not only transformed the company's financial strategy but also underscored the potential of Bitcoin as a hedge against fiat currency depreciation.

Key Actions and Developments

1. Initial Investment:

   • In August 2020, MicroStrategy announced its first purchase of 21,454 Bitcoins for $250 million, declaring Bitcoin as its primary treasury reserve asset.

   • This move was justified by Saylor as a hedge against inflation and a means to preserve shareholder value in the face of a declining US dollar.

2. Subsequent Purchases:

   • Over the following months and years, MicroStrategy continued to acquire Bitcoin, using both cash reserves and proceeds from convertible note offerings, stock sales and other corporate borrowings.

   • As of today, the company had accumulated 226,500 Bitcoins, with an aggregate purchase price of $8.3 billion and now worth $13.8 billion.

3. Funding Strategies:

   • To finance its Bitcoin acquisitions, MicroStrategy issued convertible senior notes, raising billions of dollars at low-interest rates, taking advantage of the favorable borrowing environment.

   • The company also explored other financial instruments, such as Bitcoin-backed loans, further leveraging its Bitcoin holdings to acquire more of the cryptocurrency.

4. Impact on MicroStrategy’s Financials:

   • The strategy has resulted in substantial unrealized gains, significantly increasing the company's asset value as Bitcoin's price appreciated.

   • However, it has also introduced volatility to MicroStrategy's balance sheet, with quarterly financial reports reflecting the fluctuating market value of its Bitcoin holdings.

5. Broader Influence:

   • MicroStrategy’s bold moves have inspired other corporations to consider Bitcoin as part of their treasury management strategies.

   • Michael Saylor has become a vocal advocate for Bitcoin, frequently speaking about its benefits as a superior store of value compared to traditional fiat currencies.

Implications for a Modern Speculative Attack

MicroStrategy's approach exemplifies the concept of a speculative attack in several ways:

1. Leveraging Fiat Debt to Acquire Bitcoin:

   • By borrowing in fiat currency at low interest rates to purchase Bitcoin, MicroStrategy is betting on the depreciation of the dollar relative to Bitcoin's long-term value appreciation.

   • This mirrors the speculative attack strategy where investors borrow in a weakening currency to buy a stronger asset, expecting the asset's value to rise as the currency depreciates.

2. Influencing Market Sentiment:

   • The company’s continuous and sizable investments in Bitcoin have helped legitimize Bitcoin as a treasury asset, potentially influencing market sentiment and driving further adoption.

   • This aligns with the feedback loop described in speculative attacks, where initial movements into a stronger asset can accelerate the decline of the weaker currency.

3. Risk Management and Reward:

   • While introducing risk due to Bitcoin’s volatility, MicroStrategy's strategy also positions it for significant rewards if Bitcoin continues to appreciate as expected.

   • This high-risk, high-reward approach is characteristic of speculative attacks, where investors accept short-term volatility for the potential of long-term gains.

   • Additionally, MicroStrategy is “giving the market what it wants:” Investors have capital to deploy and have an investment mandate - maybe they can only invest in bonds; MicroStrategy convertible bonds meet their mandate, provide downside risk protection and have some Bitcoin upside

MicroStrategy’s Bitcoin Treasury policy represents a modern, real-world application of the speculative attack principles outlined in Pierre Rochard's "Speculative Attack" paper. By leveraging fiat debt to acquire Bitcoin, the company is actively participating in a strategy that challenges traditional fiat currencies' stability and underscores Bitcoin’s potential as a superior store of value. This case study not only illustrates the mechanics of a speculative attack but also highlights Bitcoin's evolving role in corporate finance and its impact on global monetary systems.

---

Relevance of Conclusions Today

The core conclusions of Rochard’s paper remain highly relevant:

• Hedge Against Inflation: Bitcoin's role as a hedge against inflation has become more pronounced, especially in economies experiencing significant currency depreciation.

• Global Reserve Currency: While Bitcoin has not yet achieved the status of a global reserve currency, its increasing acceptance and adoption suggest a trajectory towards greater prominence in the global financial system.

Conclusion

Pierre Rochard's 2014 paper, "Speculative Attack," foresaw the potential for Bitcoin to disrupt fiat currencies through mechanisms historically reserved for assets like gold. Over the past decade, Bitcoin's increased liquidity, broader adoption, and the economic vulnerabilities of fiat currencies have underscored the paper’s insights. As central banks continue to navigate economic challenges, Bitcoin's fixed supply, decentralized nature, and ease of transfer maintain its appeal as a hedge against fiat instability. Thus, the speculative attack hypothesis remains a compelling narrative, highlighting Bitcoin's evolving role in the global financial ecosystem.

Not financial or legal advice, for entertainment only, do your own homework.  I hope you find this post useful as you chart your personal financial course and Build a Bitcoin Fortress in 2024.    

Thanks for following my work. Always remember: freedom, health and positivity!  

Please also check out my Bitcoin Fortress Podcast on all your favorite streaming platforms. I do a weekly Top Bitcoin News update every week on Sunday, focused on current items of interest to the Bitcoin community. Please check it out if you haven’t already. Also now on Fountain, where you can earn Bitcoin just for listening to your favorite podcasts.

Follow me on Nostr:

npub122fpu8lwu2eu2zfmrymcfed9tfgeray5quj78jm6zavj78phnqdsu3v4h5

If you’re looking for more great Bitcoin signal, check out friend of the show Pleb Underground here.

Lightning tips appreciated here.